HARARE – The High Court has ordered the Zimbabwe Revenue Authority (ZIMRA) to refund any customs duty unlawfully charged to a returning resident who imported a US$130,000 car, after ruling that the tax authority had acted irrationally in refusing to recognise her ownership of the vehicle.

Justice Regis Dembure set aside a decision by the Commissioner of Customs and Excise refusing Tererai Moyo suspension of duty, ruling that she had satisfied the legal requirements for proving ownership of the vehicle for at least six months before returning to Zimbabwe.

The court also ordered ZIMRA to determine and refund any customs duty that was not lawfully payable within 30 days, after Moyo had been forced to pay US$148,200 in customs duty, VAT and surcharges under protest to avoid forfeiture of her vehicle.

The judge criticised ZIMRA for repeatedly changing its reasons for rejecting the application and attempting to introduce fresh grounds of opposition during the court proceedings.

“She had no power to disregard the peremptory provisions of s 9NO(2) and still claim to have made a valid decision,” Dembure said, referring to the Commissioner.

The judge added that the decision was made without considering the statutory requirements governing ownership of vehicles imported by returning residents.

Moyo, who had lived in South Africa for 31 years, returned to Zimbabwe on July 12, 2025, and sought suspension of duty on her 2024 Dodge Ram TRX under the Customs and Excise (Suspension) Regulations.

She had purchased the vehicle from US Trucks, a South African company acting as an agent for Dodge Ram vehicles sourced from the United States, for US$130,000.

The purchase invoice was issued on October 15, 2024, while the full purchase price was paid through a bank transfer on November 27, 2024, using funds from an account she shared with her husband.

The vehicle was delivered to South Africa on February 22, 2025, before being placed in a bonded warehouse pending its export to Zimbabwe, as Moyo intended to benefit from the returning-resident duty provisions.

However, ZIMRA initially rejected her application at Beitbridge Border Post on the basis that she had not produced a vehicle registration book showing the Dodge Ram registered in her name.

Her subsequent appeal to the regional manager was also dismissed, with the authority insisting that registration in her name was necessary to establish ownership for the prescribed six-month period.

The Commissioner later upheld the rejection on September 25, 2025, advancing a different argument that US Trucks had retained ownership because it appeared as the consignee on the shipping documents and had kept the vehicle in its bonded warehouse.

Moyo was ordered to settle the outstanding duties and storage costs by October 11, 2025, failing which the vehicle would be forfeited to the State.

She paid US$148,200 under protest while pursuing the legal challenge.

In his ruling, Dembure said the law clearly prescribed two requirements for establishing ownership under section 9NO(2) of the Customs and Excise (Suspension) Regulations: the vehicle must have been in physical existence and fully paid for by the immigrant at least six months before arrival in Zimbabwe.

The judge said the use of the word “shall” made the requirements mandatory, leaving ZIMRA with no authority to introduce additional conditions once they had been met.

“The provisions of s 9NO(2), therefore, give no room for the Commissioner to add any further requirements once the two requirements that the motor vehicle was in physical existence and that it was fully paid by the immigrant for at least six months before the time of his or her arrival have been established,” he said.

Dembure rejected ZIMRA’s argument that Moyo had to demonstrate physical possession, use and control of the vehicle to establish ownership.

“An owner does not necessarily have to have continuous physical control or use of the thing to retain ownership. Ownership and possession are not necessarily one thing, although at law possession of movable property raises a presumption of ownership,” he said.

He also ruled that a vehicle registration book was not proof of ownership, citing previous court decisions on the legal distinction between registration and ownership.

The judge found that the Commissioner had ignored the relevant statutory provisions and instead relied on the fact that US Trucks appeared as the consignee on the bill of lading.

The supplier’s letter had confirmed that Moyo became the owner after paying the purchase price in full on November 27, 2024.

Dembure said the vehicle had existed for more than six months before her return and that its purchase price had been fully paid within the prescribed period.

He further rejected ZIMRA’s attempt to argue in court that Moyo had not personally paid for the vehicle because the bank transfer had been made by her husband.

The judge said the source of the money used by a purchaser to discharge an obligation to pay for property was irrelevant under the regulations.

“The words ‘fully paid for by the immigrant at least six months before the time of his or her arrival’ must be read in their context and not in vacuo,” he said.

He added: “The said words do not say that the payment must be personally made by the immigrant.”

The court found that payment made by a third party on behalf of a purchaser could discharge the purchaser’s obligation, provided the purchase price was paid in full.

Dembure said ZIMRA could not introduce the payment issue as a new basis for refusing the application when its officials had never questioned it during the administrative process.

“The administrative authority is, therefore, bound by its decision and the reasoning behind it. It is not given a second bite of the cherry on review to argue different reasons from what it formulated before arriving at the impugned decision,” he said.

The judge was particularly critical of the authority for producing three different decisions through the shift manager, regional manager and Commissioner, all rejecting Moyo’s application on different grounds.

He said it would be unfair to send the matter back for another full reconsideration of ownership after the authority had already made three decisions on the same issue.

“Surely Mr Marange cannot seek the same authority that has already made three different decisions, only to waste more time by being asked to make the same decision a fourth time,” Dembure said.

“To countenance that would be to perpetuate a serious miscarriage of justice.”

The court, however, noted that recognition of Moyo’s ownership did not automatically settle the entire question of the duty payable.

This was because the Dodge Ram’s value exceeded the US$40 000 threshold provided for under the regulations, an issue the Commissioner had not determined when rejecting the application.

The judge said ZIMRA must now calculate what amount, if any, was not properly payable under the applicable regulations and refund it.

The court consequently set aside the Commissioner’s September 25, 2025, decision, formally declared Moyo the owner of the vehicle for purposes of section 9NO(2) and (3), and directed the Commissioner to give effect to the ruling.

ZIMRA was ordered to make any applicable refund within 30 days and pay Moyo’s legal costs.