Divided opinion over Malema’s banishment

Some Zimbabweans applaud the decision by South Africa’s ruling party to ban renegade Julius Malema, but others believe that the African National Congress cannot afford to ignore his populist economic agenda.

JOHANNESBURG – Zimbabweans responded in various ways to the suspension last week of Julius Malema, the firebrand former president of the ANC Youth League, whose declarations unnerved politicians and investors alike.

Malema was banned for five years from the party after an ANC disciplinary committee found him guilty of sowing division and bringing the party into disrepute by urging regime change in neighbouring Botswana and swearing at a journalist.

Malema said he would appeal the suspension, saying the “gloves were off and it was time to confront and fight the enemy".

South African financial markets rallied on news of his suspension – investors were shaken by his calls for nationalization of mines and Zimbabwe-style land reform.

Analysts said Malema seemed to model his thinking on the policies of President Robert Mugabe's Zanu (PF). The ANC recently accused the Zimbabwean party of “influencing” Malema’s stances on mine nationalization and land reform.

However, Zimbabwean political commentator, Alex Magaisa, a lecturer at Kent University in the United Kingdom, said Malema may have been flawed as an individual in his politics, but it would be a mistake for the ANC not to address his economic agenda.

“I think it’s actually a cause for introspection in terms of whatever views he represented and I think that South Africa needs to address those issues as much as Zimbabweans needed to address the issues of minority ownership of resources in the country. Not addressing them, I think, is an error,” Magaisa said

Analyst, Rejoice Ngwenya, said that while Malema enjoyed strong support among youths, the decision by the ANC showed it is a party capable of reining in extremists.

“The ANC has shown its capacity to reign in on over-enthusiastic renegades that defy the order of institutional organizations. They sent a stronger message that their party can institute disciplinary measures even to people who believe they have strong roots.”

South Africa-based political commentator Paul Chimhosva said the Malema saga was typical of the drama seen in African liberation movements.

Post published in: Opinions & Analysis

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *