HARARE – The High Court has acquitted a former Geo Pomona Waste Management procurement boss who was facing fraud charges over an alleged scheme to inflate quotations for the supply of 80 New Jersey kerb barriers, ruling that the State failed to produce sufficient evidence linking him to the alleged fraud.

Justice Neville Wamambo overturned a magistrate’s decision compelling Sailus Sunguro to defend himself, finding that the prosecution had failed to establish a prima facie case showing that he knowingly participated in a fraudulent misrepresentation.

Sunguro had been jointly charged with Stanley Chikwena over allegations that they inflated quotations for the supply of 80 kerb barriers to Geo Pomona, a waste management company headed by businessman Delish Nguwaya.

The State alleged that, on January 30, 2026, the two misrepresented the cost of the barriers through inflated quotations, including one attributed to ZIMTILES which quoted US$437 per unit, bringing the total to US$34 960.

Sunguro, who was Geo Pomona’s head of procurement, was accused of using the disputed quotation in a comparative schedule alongside quotations from other suppliers, including Royal Precast.

But Wamambo ruled that the prosecution had failed to establish that Sunguro authored or manipulated the disputed quotation, knew it was fraudulent or connived with his co-accused to deceive the company.

“The court must guard against converting the existence of an irregular transaction into an inference of criminal participation by every person who handled the relevant documents,” the judge said.

The court found that Sunguro’s role in sourcing quotations and preparing comparative schedules was part of his ordinary procurement duties, a position acknowledged by State witnesses during cross-examination.

The judge said the prosecution had failed to provide sufficient evidence connecting him to the alleged falsehood or establishing the criminal intention required to sustain a fraud charge.

“Suspicion sufficient to justify an investigation is not necessarily evidence sufficient to require an accused person to enter upon his defence for fraud,” Wamambo said.

The case centred partly on a disputed ZIMTILES quotation, which the prosecution argued had not been properly authorised under the supplier’s internal procedures.

However, evidence from ZIMTILES witnesses was contested, with operations manager Tichaona Mugano telling the court that the quotation was genuine and official.

Mugano also testified that he had no evidence against Sunguro and nothing to assist the court in establishing his guilt or innocence.

The judge noted that the evidence showed ZIMTILES could quote for products it did not manufacture and source them from other suppliers. The fact that the company did not manufacture New Jersey kerb barriers was therefore not, on its own, proof that the quotation was fraudulent.

The prosecution also relied on an apparent price discrepancy involving Royal Precast. One quotation reflected US$356 per unit, while another showed US$240.

But Royal Precast sales representative Emmanuel Ziwakaya told the court that the higher-priced barriers had additional specifications, including double steel reinforcement and extended hooks, which accounted for the difference.

The State witnesses also acknowledged that the cheaper quotations obtained during an internal investigation related to products that did not meet the specifications required by Geo Pomona’s user department.

Wamambo said a difference in price could not, without more, establish inflation or fraud where the products being compared had different specifications.

The judge further rejected the argument that Sunguro’s alleged failure to conduct due diligence was enough to establish criminal liability.

“A breach of a workplace procedure, negligence in the performance of official duties and the intentional or knowingly risk-taking conduct required for fraud are distinct matters,” the judgment states.

The court said that even if Sunguro had a responsibility to verify quotations, the State still had to establish that he knew the disputed quotation was false or deliberately used it to deceive Geo Pomona.

It also found that the evidence did not sufficiently establish connivance between Sunguro and Chikwena, noting that witnesses from ZIMTILES and Royal Precast had not linked him to the alleged scheme.

The judge stressed that proof of a questionable procurement transaction was not enough to establish fraud against everyone who handled the documents.

“The prejudice must be connected to the alleged misrepresentation, and the applicant’s participation must be supported by evidence,” the court said.

Sunguro had approached the High Court after Provincial Magistrate Kuhudzai dismissed his application for discharge at the close of the State case on August 26, 2026.

He argued that the prosecution had failed to establish the essential elements of fraud and that compelling him to defend himself would improperly shift the burden of proof.

The National Prosecuting Authority opposed the review, arguing that the evidence surrounding the ZIMTILES quotation, the pricing discrepancies and Sunguro’s role in preparing the comparative schedule established a prima facie case.

However, Justice Wamambo found that the magistrate had misapplied the legal test governing discharge at the close of the State case.

The judge said an accused person should not be forced to enter upon a defence merely to fill gaps in the prosecution’s evidence.

The court accordingly set aside the magistrate’s decision and substituted it with an order granting Sunguro’s application for discharge under Section 198(3) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act.

He was found not guilty and acquitted of fraud.

The judge made it clear that the ruling was confined to the case against Sunguro and did not determine the position of his co-accused or establish that the procurement transaction was free from irregularities.