ANC risked Madiba's health at Zuma rally

The Sunday Times has established that Mandela was fetched from his
Houghton home early on Sunday by his grandson and former ANC Youth
League leader Fikile Mbalula, who now heads the party's campaign for
the April 22 election.

Against all precedent, he was flown without proper security
arrangements from Lanseria airport to Mthatha in a private aircraft
that belongs to an unidentified businessman.

Senior police officers, who were in the convoy that escorted Mandela
from Mthatha to Idutywa, said his aircraft made three attempts to land
in very bad weather before touching down at 11am, an hour behind
schedule.

Sources familiar with the day's events said Mandela, who usually starts
preparing for bed around 4pm, was only brought home well after dark.
It really was very bad and irresponsible treatment of the old man,
said one confidant. A family friend added: Shame, the old man really
doesn't deserve this kind of nonsense at this time of his life. It's a
very sorry story.

The Nelson Mandela Foundation, which has managed his travel
arrangements since he stepped down as president in 1999, was unaware of
the visit until late the day before, and was not allowed to help, to
make plans or asked for advice.

In fact, we were not aware that he was going until almost the last
minute. We were taken as much by surprise as many other people,
foundation chairman Jakes Gerwel told the Sunday Times yesterday.

He said the trip had been made with none of the usual consideration for
Mandela's security or physical comfort. It has been consistently the
practice over the years since he left the president's office that we
(the foundation) have been involved. I can't remember a case where we
were not involved, Gerwel said.

VIP commander Senior Superintendent Jabulani Magwa said his office was
notified about Mandela's arrival late on Saturday, February 14, and
instructed to dispatch security for the following day.

A senior official said they would normally be advised a few days in advance of Mandela's arrival in the province.

Among violations of the usual protocols that protect South Africa's most famous citizen were:

Mandela's presidential protection unit team is usually given time to
assess the travel plan and to have a team waiting for him on arrival at
his destination. This was not done;

His personal security team should check the overland route he will
take days in advance. This was also not done. Instead, it was delegated
to Zuma's team, which violated the rule that each team must manage only
its own principal;

Mandela usually flies in specific air force jets known to be able to
accommodate his physical needs. Again, this was not done. The aircraft
he flew in was privately owned, its security was not checked and it was
not suited to his needs;

If he is flying in any other plane it has to be security vetted and checked for his specification —not done

Mandela rarely uses secondary airports for security reasons and the
risk of being mobbed. When he does, special arrangements are made for
his arrival and departure. This was not done;

Madiba's staff always check venues to ensure he can safely negotiate
paths and stairs and can be comfortably seated. It was not done and he
had to be virtually lifted onto the stage;

Mandela usually has a pre-flight medical and flies with a personal physician. It was not done;

Special arrangements are usually made with the nearest hospital to
ensure that a suitable team is on hand and familiar with his medical
file. It was not done; and

A helicopter is usually on stand-by within short flying distance to
airlift him to the nearest big urban centre in an emergency. It was not
arranged.

Immediately after landing, Mandela and his entourage travelled to
Idutywa, where the ANC was holding its election rally. The police
officers said Mandela, accompanied by his grandson, his daughter,
Makaziwe, and his granddaughter, Ndileka, left for his Qunu home after
the rally at about 2pm.

They were later joined by Zuma, Mbalula, ANC Youth League president
Julius Malema and a few other Eastern Cape ANC leaders for lunch.

I'm not sure if Malema sat at the lunch table, but he was also there, said one officer.

Shortly thereafter, Mandela and Zuma headed to the Mthatha airport in
separate convoys, flying off at about 5pm in different aircraft. One
officer said Mandela appeared relaxed.

Many ANC veterans and members of the current leadership were shocked to
see Mandela at the rally, because he has said repeatedly through his
staff that he does not want to be involved in the election campaign.

He made the point to me a number of times: I don't want to be
involved and I don't want to do any electioneering.' It's not something
we made up, it comes from him, Gerwel said.

Supporters of Zuma's bid for the presidency have been piling on the
pressure for a Mandela endorsement in the face of COPE, the breakaway
party led by Terror Lekota and Mbhazima Shilowa.

Sources close to the family said Mandla took Zuma and Mbalula to see
Mandela at his home two weeks ago. It is not known what was discussed
there.

The sources said Mandla often takes visitors to the Houghton home, thereby avoiding any control by the foundation.

Close associates said Mandela's former wife, Winnie Madikizela-Mandela,
and his daughter, Zindzi, were livid about the way he had been
press-ganged into a political endorsement of Zuma and the ANC.

A family friend pointed out that Mandla and his aunt, Makaziwe, had
only recently taken an interest in ANC politics after being essentially
apolitical for years.

ANC spokesman Lindiwe Zulu said yesterday the foundation was not
responsible for Mandela's travel. This has absolutely nothing to do
with the foundation. Mandela's political life — in the ANC — has
nothing to do with the foundation. Maybe we need to check what are the
responsibilities of the foundation and of the political party and its
members. These are two separate things. What the foundation does is for
anti-Aids, his social responsibility. It absolutely has nothing to do
with his political work, she said.

But Gerwel said the former president had given the task to the foundation years ago.

The foundation has been charged by Madiba to be what the Americans
would call his post-presidential office, so his security, which
includes his health, has been entrusted to our care. He was not
necessarily put at risk — it's just that it was outside of the normal
practice of logistical arrangements.

Responding to the suggestion that Mandela deserved better than to be
dragged around the country to help the ANC overcome its mistakes, Zulu
said it was his responsibility to do that.

Mandela still has (his) full senses. .. He won't do what he does not
want to do. If anyone has the issue, it's their issue, it's now our
issue. As far as we are concerned, Mandela is still a political
person, she said.

People who have visited Mandela recently said he showed little interest in recent developments within the party.