The Flamboyant Hotel in MasvingoHARARE – For years, Masvingo’s most famous hotel was known as “Eddison Zvobgo’s hotel” – a reference to the late former Zanu PF politician who was heavily involved in its construction and management.
Zvobgo died in 2004, but his family continued running the facility, not always on the terms agreed during negotiations for its financing.
Now, a pension fund that helped finance the construction of Flamboyant Hotel wants out, while Zvobgo’s survivors risk walking away with nothing amid mounting historic debts.
The High Court on November 10 registered an arbitral award valuing the Mining Industry Pension Fund’s (MIPF) 48 percent stake in the company that owns the hotel at US$2,970,958.51, rejecting an attempt by the hotel operator to have the award set aside.
In dismissing an application by Perce (Private) Limited, Justice Lucy Mungwari said the company was effectively asking the court to do what Article 34 of the Model Law, set out in the schedule to the Arbitration Act, does not permit.
“A party who fails on the merits before the tribunal it chose cannot use Article 34 to obtain a second hearing,” the judge said.
The court’s role in such applications, she explained, was limited. It was not concerned with whether the arbitrator had reached the correct decision, but whether he had acted within his mandate and whether the outcome was so outrageous that it could not be allowed to stand.
“A court hearing an Article 34 application does not ask whether the arbitrator was right. It asks whether he stayed within his remit and, if he did, whether the result is so outrageous that it cannot be allowed to stand,” the judge said, finding that Perce had established neither ground.
The company was ordered to pay MIPF’s legal costs on the ordinary scale. The pension fund, represented by Advocate Thabani Mpofu, had sought punitive costs, arguing that the challenge was intended merely to delay payment.
But the judge said Perce had exercised its legal right within the prescribed time and advanced its arguments responsibly, with reference to legal authority.
Losing an application did not, by itself, amount to an abuse of court process, she said.
The dispute dates back to 1991, when Perce, a company linked to Zvobgo, borrowed money from MIPF and Standard Chartered Bank Zimbabwe to buy the land on which the hotel stands. It subsequently fell into default.
In February 1995, the three parties signed a shareholders’ agreement to restructure the debt. A special purpose vehicle, New Corporate Investments (Seven) (Private) Limited (NewCo), was established and took over the hotel property, which Perce then leased back.
MIPF and Standard Chartered each held 48 percent of NewCo, with Perce owning the remaining 4 percent. Perce later acquired the bank’s shares, leaving it with a 52 percent controlling stake against MIPF’s 48 percent.
Although the written lease expired on December 31, 2006, Perce remained in occupation. MIPF’s chief executive told the arbitration that direct rental payments to the fund stopped sometime between 2009 and 2011.
“On MIPF’s evidence, board meetings were frustrated, no financial statements for NewCo were prepared after 2000 and no rent or dividend was paid,” the judgment records.
The dispute eventually came to a head when Perce exercised its option to buy MIPF’s shares, but the parties failed to agree on a price.
A consent order granted by Justice Joseph Mafusire on June 2, 2022, referred the dispute to arbitration, directing the arbitrator to determine the share price, any dividend payable to MIPF arising from rentals, and the amount of those rentals.
The arbitrator, Godknows Hofisi, a lawyer and chartered accountant, delivered his award on August 8, 2025.
He valued the hotel property at US$3,633,000, comprising US$433,000 for the land and US$3.2 million for the buildings.
He also calculated rent and interest owed by Perce to NewCo for the period from 2009 to June 30, 2025, at US$3,723,574.18, and fixed future rentals from July 1, 2025, at US$18,900 a month.
The arbitrator made provision for NewCo’s estimated income tax liability of US$1,167,077.28, including a 20 percent allowance for penalties, before arriving at a net asset value of US$6,189,496.90 as at June 30, 2025. MIPF’s 48 percent interest was consequently valued at US$2,970,958.51.
He made no separate award for dividends.
Perce challenged the award on several grounds, arguing that Hofisi had exceeded his mandate by determining rentals after declining to find that a dividend was payable. It said incorporating the rental claims into NewCo’s net asset value artificially inflated the price of MIPF’s shares.
The company also argued that the award violated the principle of privity of contract because MIPF was not a party to the lease between Perce and NewCo. It accused the arbitrator of improperly extending an expired lease and imposing rentals that the parties had never agreed to.
Perce, represented by Advocate Tawanda Zhuwarara, further contended that rental claims which had not been recognised through a board resolution, audited financial statements or a dividend declaration were improperly treated as company assets.
It also accused the arbitrator of failing to deal properly with its defence of prescription, arguing that the cumulative defects rendered the award contrary to public policy.
MIPF opposed the application, arguing that Perce had effectively accepted the award by engaging in discussions about payment after it was issued. It also accused the company of bringing what was essentially an appeal disguised as an application to set aside an arbitral award.
Justice Mungwari rejected the acquiescence argument, saying discussions about payment did not necessarily amount to acceptance of liability.
“A discussion about paying a sum that an award has fixed is as consistent with an attempt to settle a disputed liability as with acceptance of it,” the judge said.
“Commercial parties in a continuing relationship, as these parties are through NewCo, routinely talk while litigating.”
The judge pointed to an email dated September 30, 2025, in which Perce indicated that its final position on the award would partly depend on the outcome of a meeting between the parties.
“That contemporaneous reservation is inconsistent with an unequivocal acceptance of the award,” she said, adding that doubtful cases of acquiescence should be resolved against the party alleging it.
On the central question of whether Hofisi had exceeded his mandate by determining rentals without awarding a dividend, the judge sided with MIPF.
She said Perce had reversed the proper sequence of the issues referred to arbitration by arguing that rentals could only be determined after a dividend had been found payable.
“The rental determination is the input to the dividend enquiry, not its product,” the judge said.
“If rentals could be determined only after a dividend had been found payable, the dividend enquiry could never start.”
The arbitrator’s decision not to make a separate dividend award did not mean he had failed to determine the issue, she added.
“An arbitrator who considers the question referred to him and answers it, even by declining to award anything, has not failed to decide it and has not strayed outside it.”
The judge also found that incorporating the rental claims into NewCo’s net asset value was consistent with the shareholders’ agreement, which required the share price to reflect the company’s net asset value.
“A debt owed to a company is one of its assets,” the judgment states.
“Leaving it out would have understated NewCo’s value, and the beneficiary of that understatement would have been the debtor, Perce, who was also the buyer of the shares.”
Perce’s argument that the rental receivables had not been reflected in company resolutions, audited accounts or invoices went to the method of valuation rather than the arbitrator’s jurisdiction, the judge said.
“If the arbitrator answered it wrongly, that is an error within his jurisdiction. It is not an excursion outside it.”
The judge then turned to Perce’s reliance on public policy, stressing that demonstrating an error by an arbitrator, even a serious one, was not enough to have an award set aside.
Drawing on the Supreme Court’s decision in Zimbabwe Electricity Supply Authority v Maposa, she said the threshold was a “palpable inequity” so far-reaching and outrageous in its defiance of logic or acceptable moral standards that it would intolerably offend Zimbabwe’s conception of justice.
On the question of privity of contract, Justice Mungwari said the award did not allow MIPF to enforce rights under a lease to which it was not a party.
The arbitrator had expressly acknowledged that MIPF was not a party to the lease and had not ordered Perce to pay rentals directly to the pension fund.
“Privity of contract governs who may enforce a contract. It does not stop a valuer from recognising that a company has a claim against a third party when valuing that company,” the judge said.
She also noted that the mandate to determine rentals arose from a consent order to which Perce had agreed.
“It cannot now say that public policy forbids the arbitrator from doing what Perce asked the court to order him to do.”
The argument that the lessor was absent from the proceedings was also rejected. NewCo had been cited in the arbitration but did not participate, while Perce itself held 52 percent of its shares.
The judge noted that Perce had put the existence of a lease in issue by arguing that there was no cause of action. Hofisi subsequently found that the lease had been tacitly relocated, relying on evidence including Perce’s continued occupation of the property and rental payments in United States dollars after 2009.
“That is a finding of fact and law within the issue Perce raised. It is not the invention of a contract,” the judge said.
Perce’s own valuation witnesses had also accepted that rent was accruing to NewCo, with one acknowledging that the company owed about US$1 million.
Justice Mungwari further rejected the argument that the arbitrator had invented his own formula for calculating rentals.
Hofisi had applied the formula in the original lease, which provided for rentals equivalent to 20 percent of accommodation revenue and 7.5 percent of other revenue.
He used Perce’s own income statements for the period from 2009 to 2018. For subsequent years, he relied on estimates based on the hotel’s capacity, tariffs and occupancy data after Perce failed to provide the relevant figures.
The judge accepted that another arbitrator might have opted to calculate future rentals periodically using actual revenue rather than fixing them at a monthly amount.
But that was a debatable choice in quantifying rentals under the lease, not evidence that the arbitrator had strayed beyond his mandate.
“That is a debatable choice about how to quantify rent under paragraph 3(c). It is not a frolic.”
The judge did, however, identify an error in Hofisi’s treatment of the prescription defence.
The arbitrator had reasoned that evidence elicited during cross-examination could not be used by the party conducting the cross-examination to establish its special plea of prescription.
“I am of the opinion that evidence is evidence, whichever party elicits it,” Justice Mungwari said.
But she found that the misdirection did not reach the threshold required to set aside the award on public policy grounds.
Perce had failed to lead its two expert witnesses on prescription or call an officer or employee to address the relevant dates. The arbitrator’s conclusion that the defence had not been proved therefore followed from the way the company had presented its case.
The judge also rejected Perce’s complaint that the rental claims should not have been recognised without a board resolution, audited accounts or a dividend declaration.
On the evidence accepted by the arbitrator, the absence of those formalities was itself a consequence of Perce’s control of NewCo.
“An arbitrator who declines to let a controlling shareholder benefit from the company records it has not produced does not violate a fundamental principle of law or justice,” the judge said.
She further noted that Hofisi had ruled in Perce’s favour, or partly in its favour, on several issues. He rejected MIPF’s depreciated replacement cost valuation of US$7,596,000, made provision for NewCo’s tax liability despite MIPF’s objection and declined to award a separate dividend.
“That is not the work of an arbitrator who has not applied his mind to the question or has totally misunderstood the issue,” the judge said.
“His conclusions may be debated. They are not outrageous, and Article 34 does not permit this court to substitute its own valuation for his.”
“Perce may consider the result wrong,” the judge said. “That is not a basis for setting it aside.”


